We consider the nature of thermally stratified flow in a closed cylinder ro
tating about the direction of gravity under conditions appropriate for terr
estrial laboratory experiments. Motion is driven by centrifugal buoyancy, w
ith outflow near the cold disk and inflow near the hot disk. Although simil
arity solutions for the infinite disk open-geometry problem exist and are e
asily found, even analytically in certain limits, there remain questions ab
out the applicability of these spatially simplified models in a closed geom
etry with a vertical sidewall. This paper compares theoretical self-similar
core solutions with computational simulations constructed to satisfy a wid
e range of sidewall thermal boundary conditions; insulating, conducting (wi
th a linear temperature profile up the wall), hot (isothermal), or cold. Th
e width of penetration of sidewall influence in toward the axis of rotation
depends on the sidewall thermal boundary condition. However, as the cylind
er radius is increased for a fixed height, a substantial region of the cont
ainer about the axis is accurately described by the thermocline solutions o
f the theory. The non-self-similar region at large radius can include separ
ation of the lower outflow boundary layer, a feature not evident in previou
s studies of this problem.