Community elders (N = 330) were interviewed by telephone twice ist bas
eline using both computer-assisted telephone interviews (CATI) and nur
se clinicians, and at four-month follow-up using CATI to collect alter
native paraprofessional home care adequacy measures. Measurement forma
t influenced both reliability and observed levels of adequacy but alte
rnative adequacy measures converged and were not closely linked to fun
ctional status. The predictive validity of measures based on clinical
standards with respect to health outcomes was also demonstrated. These
findings support emerging approaches in primary care and home health
quality measurement that consider multiple dimensions of user response
to formal and informal care.