Mc. Tierney et al., Prediction of probable Alzheimer disease in patients with symptoms suggestive of memory impairment - Value of the mini-mental state examination, ARCH FAM M, 9(6), 2000, pp. 527-532
Background: The Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) is a widely used diagn
ostic tool for dementia. Its use as a predictive indicator of probable Alzh
eimer disease (AD) has not been established.
Objectives: To determine the accuracy of the MMSE in predicting emergent AD
in a sample of patients who were referred because of symptoms suggestive o
f memory problems and to determine whether an abbreviated version of the MM
SE could be developed that would be as accurate as the full MMSE in predict
ing emergent AD.
Design: Inception cohort of participants with symptoms suggestive of memory
impairment by their family physicians were given baseline assessments, inc
luding MMSE. After 2 years, the participants' conditions were diagnosed fol
lowing the standard criterion for AD. Diagnosticians were blind to baseline
scores.
Setting and Participants: One hundred eighty-three community-residing parti
cipants were referred by their family physicians to a university teaching h
ospital research investigation. After baseline screening, 165 participants
were included in the study who did not have dementia and had no identifiabl
e cause for memory impairment. After 2 years, 29 participants met criteria
for AD, 98 did not develop dementia, 18 developed vascular lesions or non-A
D dementia, and 20 did not return.
Main Outcome Measurer Diagnostic classification of AD or no evidence of dem
entia.
Results: Logistic regression model was significant. At a cutoff score of 24
or less, sensitivity was 31%; specificity, 96%; with a likelihood ratio of
7.75. A reduced model of 2 subtests was identified with a sensitivity of 4
1%; specificity, 98%; with a likelihood ratio of 20.70.
Conclusions: Results suggest that the full or abbreviated MMSE is useful in
predicting emergent AD in patients with postive test results. However, iri
s not recommended for use as a screening or diagnostic instrument since a n
egative test result did not rule out emergent AD. It is recommended as a to
ol to identify those needing closer monitoring.