L. De Grandpre et al., Early understory successional changes following clearcutting in the balsamfir-yellow birch forest, ECOSCIENCE, 7(1), 2000, pp. 92-100
Community response to disturbance is influenced by species life history and
the nature of disturbance. In this study we investigated the effects of cl
earcutting on the early successional changes of an understory species commu
nity in the balsam fir-yellow birch forest type of the Lower St. Lawrence R
egion of Quebec, Canada. Clearcuts of 5, 10 and 20 years were sampled along
with mature stands. In each of these communities, ten circular quadrats of
400 m(2) were established where the percent cover of herb, fern, and shrub
species was estimated. Along a 150-m transect starting in the middle of re
ach quadrat, the seedling density of commercial tree species was measured i
n ten 4-m(2) plots. Detrended Correspondence Analysis (DCA; cover values) w
as used to describe the early successional changes in the understory commun
ity and a Correspondence Analysis (CA) was used with presence/absence data
to evaluate the compositional differences. The results revealed a time grad
ient associated with understory community changes, in which the first 10 ye
ars of successional changes are characterized by the dominance of shade int
olerant species. A decrease in the floristic heterogeneity was associated w
ith clearcut logging. Small herb species with a shallow root system were mo
st affected by logging. For commercial tree seedlings, the changes followin
g clearcutting were characterized by a decrease over time in the density an
d stocking of shade intolerant and mid-tolerant species (principally white
and yellow birches). In the older clearcuts, sugar maple appeared to be the
dominant commercial species in the seedling understory. The results sugges
ted that clearcut logging in the balsam fir-yellow birch forest type may co
ntribute to rapidly shifting the seedling understory composition towards do
minance by shade tolerant species. This situation may be related to the dom
inance of mountain maple in the understory of old clearcuts that contribute
to reducing the available light in the understory, thus increasing mortali
ty of shads intolerant seedling species. Clearcutting may also have deleter
ious effects on some understory herb species that need particular condition
s before re-establishing in a site. Logging tends to reduce micro-site hete
rogeneity over large extended areas-a situation that may preclude the re-es
tablishment of some late successional herb species.