We discuss the validity of generalized Debye-Huckel (GDH) equation proposed
by Fisher et al. [B. P. Lee and M. E. Fisher, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 2906 (1
996); Europhys. Lett. 39, 611 (1997); M. N. Tamashiro, Y. Levin, and M. C.
Barbosa, Physica A 268, 24 (1999)], from the functional integral point of v
iew. The GDH theory considers fluctuations around prescribed densities of p
ositive and negative charges. Hence, we first formulate a density functiona
l integral expression for the canonical system of Coulomb gas, and also dem
onstrate that this is a dual form to the sine-Gordon theory. Our formalism
reveals the following: (i) The induced charge distribution around supposed
density favors not only the cancellation of additional electrostatic potent
ial like the original DH theory, but also the countervailing of chemical po
tential difference between imposed and equilibrium value. (ii) As a consequ
ence apparent charge, absent in the GDH equation, comes out in our generali
zed equation. (iii) That is, the GDH equation holds only in special cases.