The observed cosmic microwave background radiation (CMBR) dipole is ge
nerally interpreted as a Doppler effect arising from the motion of the
Earth relative to the CMBR frame. An alternative interpretation, prop
osed in the last years, is that the dipole results from ultralarge sca
le isocurvature perturbations. We examine this idea in the context of
open cosmologies and show that the isocurvature interpretation is nor
valid in an open universe, unless it is extremely close to a flat univ
erse, \Omega(0)-1\less than or similar to 10(-4).