Me. Costanza et al., Promoting mammography - Results of a randomized trial of telephone counseling and a medical practice intervention, AM J PREV M, 19(1), 2000, pp. 39-46
Background: Despite widespread promotion of mammography screening, a distin
ct minority of women have remained underusers of this effective preventive
measure. We sought to measure the effects of barrier-specific telephone cou
nseling (BSTC) and a physician-based educational intervention (MD-ED) on ma
mmography utilization among underusers of mammography screening.
Design: This was a randomized controlled trial. Women meeting criteria for
mammography underuse at baseline (grouped by practice affiliation) were ran
domized to a reminder control condition (RC group received annual mailed re
minders), BSTC or MD-ED interventions and followed for 3 years. Underuse wa
s defined by failure to get two annual or biannual mammograms over a 2- to
4-year period prior to a baseline survey.
Participants and Settings: The study included 1655 female underusers of mam
mography aged 50-80 years who were members of two health maintenance organi
zations (HMO) in central Massachusetts.
Interventions: BSTC consisted of periodic brief, scripted calls from traine
d counselors to women who had not had a mammogram in the preceding 15 month
s. Women could receive up to three annual calls during the study. MD-ED con
sisted of physician and office staff trainings aimed at improving counselin
g skills and office reminder systems.
Main Outcome Measures: Self-report of mammography use during the study peri
od was the main outcome measure. Regular use was defined as greater than or
equal to 1 mammogram every 24 months.
Results: Forty-four percent in each intervention group became regular users
compared to 42% in the RC group. Among subjects who had prior but not rece
nt mammograms at baseline, BSTC was effective (OR=1.48; 95% CI=1.04; 2.10),
and MD-ED marginally effective (OR=1.28; 95% CI=0.88, 1.85). Most recent u
sers at baseline and few never users became regular users (61% and 17%, res
pectively) regardless of intervention status.
Conclusions: Among mammography underusers BSTC modestly increases utilizati
on for former users at a reasonable cost ($726 per additional regular user)
.
(C) 2000 American Journal of Preventive Medicine.