Objectives. The aim of this study was to determine the factor structure of
three standardized memory tests: Wechsler Memory Scale-Revised (WMS-R), War
rington Recognition Memory Test WRMT), Doors and People Test (D&P). We inve
stigated whether these different standardized tests of memory are consisten
t in their evaluation of memory function, and the extent to which these tes
ts discriminate between different memory functions (e.g. recall/recognition
and verbal/non-verbal memory).
Design. Fifty patients with selective memory impairment were tested on the
WMS-R, WRMT and D&P.
Methods. Age-scaled scores from selective measures of these tests (WMS-R-ve
rbal, WMS-R-visual, WMS-R-delay, WRMT-words, WRMT-faces, D&P-people, D&P-do
ors, D&P-shapes, Dg(P-names) were used as input to a factor analysis.
Results. Maximum likelihood factor analysis yielded a three-factor solution
consistent with a theoretically motivated fractionation of memory function
into recall and recognition components. Recognition performance, but not r
ecall performance, showed dissociation into visual and verbal components.
Conclusions. The WMS-R, WRMT and D&P are highly consistent in their assessm
ent of memory function. The results of the factor analysis are consistent w
ith a theoretically motivated fractionation of recall and recognition memor
y. They are also partially consistent with a dissociation between visual an
d verbal memory function.