Ga. Doody et al., Predictors of admission to a high-security hospital of people with intellectual disability with and without schizophrenia, J INTEL DIS, 44, 2000, pp. 130-137
Admission to secure hospital facilities is a rare outcome for people with i
ntellectual disability with or without concomitant psychosis. The present s
tudy compares people with mild intellectual disability with and without sch
izophrenia resident in the Scottish and Northern Irish State Hospital, Cars
tairs, to matched mild intellectual disability controls, also with and with
out schizophrenia, in the community. It is hoped that this study may identi
fy socio-demographic, clinical or historical predictors which may lead to a
dmission to secure hospital facilities for people with mild intellectual di
sability. One hundred and eight subjects were identified from two previous
studies which concerned State Hospital patients and patients with intellect
ual disability with and without schizophrenia. Four experimental groups wer
e derived: (1) 14 individuals with comorbid intellectual disability and sch
izophrenia who had been resident in the State Hospital; (2) 34 comorbid com
munity control subjects; (3) 33 individuals with intellectual disability an
d no psychosis who had been resident in the State Hospital; and (4) 27 comm
unity control subjects with mild intellectual disability. The four groups w
ere compared on a range of socio-demographic, historical and clinical varia
bles obtained from case records and subject interviews. Relative to communi
ty controls, people with intellectual disability and no psychosis in the St
ate Hospital are likely to be single, to have a later age of first psychiat
ric hospital admission, and to have a history of previous suicide attempts.
alcohol abuse or drug misuse. Subjects with comorbid intellectual disabili
ty and schizophrenia in the State Hospital are more likely to be male, to h
ave an early age of first psychiatric admission, and to have no family hist
ory of either schizophrenia or intellectual disability. Strategies aimed at
addressing suicidal behaviour, alcohol and drug misuse amongst people with
intellectual disability may facilitate a reduction in the number of admiss
ions to high-security hospitals in the UK. In people with comorbid intellec
tual disability and schizophrenia, males with an early age of onset and no
known family history are more likely to require care and treatment in a sec
ure psychiatric setting. Such comorbid subjects may be suffering from a par
ticular malignant form of schizophrenia, manifesting in childhood as cognit
ive impairment prior to the early onset of psychosis in teenage years.