The predictive capability of two comprehensive combustion codes, PCGC-3 and
FLUENT, to simulate local flame structure and combustion characteristics i
n an industrial gas-fired, flat-glass furnace is investigated. Model predic
tions are compared with experimental data from the furnace for profiles of
velocity, species concentrations, temperatures, and wall-incident radiative
heat flux. Predictions from both codes show agreement with the measured me
an velocity profiles and incident radiant flux on the crown. However, signi
ficant differences between the code predictions and measurements are observ
ed for the flame-zone temperatures and species concentrations. The observed
discrepancies may be explained by (i) uncertainties in the distributions o
f mean velocity and turbulence in the portneck, (ii) uncertainties in the p
ort-by-port stoichiometry, (iii) different grid-based approximations to the
furnace geometry made in the two codes, (iv) the assumption of infinitely
fast chemistry made in the chemical reaction model of both codes, and (v) s
implifying assumptions made in the simulations regarding the complex coupli
ng between the combustion space, batch blanket, and melt tank. The study il
lustrates the critical need for accurate boundary conditions (inlet air and
fuel flow distributions, boundary surface temperatures, etc.) and the impo
rtance of representative furnace geometry in simulating these complex indus
trial combustion systems.