Kj. Kaplan et E. Bratman, Gender, pain, and doctor involvement: High school student attitudes towarddoctor-assisted suicide, OMEGA-J D, 40(1), 1999, pp. 27-41
The present study concentrates on the attitudes of high school students tow
ard active doctor-assisted suicide as described in hypothetical doctor-pati
ent scenarios, orthogonally manipulating doctor's reaction to patient's wis
hes to end his/her life (whether discussed, accepted or encouraged), presen
ce of patient's physical pain, presence of patient's emotional pain, and th
e gender of the hypothetical patient. Doctor-assisted suicides thoroughly d
iscussed with the patient are judged to be more moral, acceptable, and "leg
al" than assisted suicides that are simply accepted by the doctor or active
ly encouraged by him. Significantly, this is not a distinction that is rele
vant in the eyes of the law. Further, the presence of both physical and emo
tional pain on the part of the patient make the patient death more acceptab
le in the eyes of high school students. This latter effect is striking, giv
en the result of the Wooddell and Kaplan (1999-2000) study showing that pat
ient depression tends to weaken acceptability of death. Finally, respondent
s, both male and female, tend to view deaths of patients of the opposite ge
nder as more acceptable than patients of the same gender.