The association between municipal fragmentation and suburban sprawl is exam
ined, based on a cross-sectional analysis of all U.S. and Canadian metropol
itan areas with more than 500,000 residents in the 1990s. Results reveal th
at this association is rather weak but significant and is sustained even wh
en the less fragmented and more compact Canadian metropolitan areas are exc
luded from the analysis. The impact of residential sprawl on fragmentation
is significant, but fragmentation does not predict sprawl. Low levels of fr
agmentation do not guarantee compact development, but lack of excessive fra
gmentation might be a precondition for compact development in North America
.