Detailed reviewing of several existing Rb/Sr datings from the West-Carpathi
an granitic massifs shows that the Rb/Sr dates older than U/Pb zircon data
are possibly caused by inclusion of high Rb/Sr samples in the sample collec
tions. Such samples, usually occurring as leucocratic veins in metamorphic
complexes, usually have higher initial Sr-87/Sr-86 ratios which results in
generating pseudo-isochrons. Therefore, there is no need for an initial mix
ing Line as suggested earlier. Some samples outlying both above and below i
sochrons may be interpreted in terms of system opening at a time different
from the initial closure. Depending on reconstructed Rb/Sr ratios late Vari
scan to Early Alpine ages are obtained for the opening. In contrast to Rb/S
r, previously published Sm/Nd data show that the initial Nd-143/Nd-144 rati
os were not homogenized making it possible to suggest end-members responsib
le for the observed variation. Such end-members are sought in (1) the peral
uminous (leuco)granites that originated through dehydration melting of gnei
sses with fairly high I-Sr and (2) gabbro/dioritic rocks occurring within g
ranite massifs or as mafic enclaves. Assimilation of supracrustal rocks by
the mafic magma could have produced either sub- to metaluminous I-type gran
itoids or peraluminous S-type granites depending on proportions of the end-
members. The varying proportions may also have been responsible for the min
eralogical and petrological differences observed between the two groups. Se
ven different sources are suggested for all the Variscan granitoids in the
Western Carpathians.