S. Wilsey et al., Ground- and excited-state surfaces for the [2+2]-photocycloaddition of alpha,beta-enones to alkenes, J AM CHEM S, 122(24), 2000, pp. 5866-5876
The potential energy surfaces of the ground state (S-0) and triplet pi pi*
(T-1) state for the cycloaddition of acrolein to ethylene have been mapped
with ab initio CASSCF calculations and the 6-31G* basis set. The results in
dicate that transition states on both the triplet and ground-state surfaces
play a part in controlling product selectivity, in accord with the experim
ental results of Weedon and co-workers. The first part of the reaction invo
lves attack of the alkene by either the alpha- or beta-carbon of the triple
t cis or trans alpha,beta-enone leading to many different anti and gauche c
onformations of a triplet biradical intermediate, which then undergoes inte
rsystem crossing to the ground-state surface. The second part of the reacti
on is controlled by the groundstate surface topology. Ring-closure to produ
cts competes with reversion to reactants; anti birodicals have a tendency t
o dissociate while gauche biradicals favor cyclobutane formation. The addit
ion of the n pi* states of acrolein to ethylene has higher barriers than fo
und for the 3(pi pi*) state. alpha-Attack is strongly disfavored as it invo
lves decoupling electrons, but the barriers for beta-attack leading to 1,6-
birdicals lie only a few kilocalories per mole higher in energy than those
on the (3)(pi pi*) surface, suggesting that in more constrained enone syste
ms the n pi* states may play a role. Two (1)(n pi*)/(3)(n pi*)/(3)(pi pi*)
crossing regions exist, the first in acrolein itself and the second in the
1,6-biradical region. In the parent system, the biradical crossing points l
ie some 16 kcal/mol above the n pi* minima, such that fast intersystem cros
sing or internal conversion is more likely to occur before the transition s
tate region. However, in more constrained systems, the reaction could proce
ed on the n pi* states into the biradical region, followed by decay through
the four-level degenerate crossing points.