F. Meric et al., Prognostic implications of pathological lymph node status after preoperative chemotherapy for operable T3N0M0 breast cancer, ANN SURG O, 7(6), 2000, pp. 435-440
Background: Although preoperative chemotherapy has become the standard of c
are for inoperable locally advanced breast cancer, its role for downstaging
resectable primary tumors is still evolving. The purpose of this study was
to determine whether the prognostic information from an axillary node diss
ection in patients with clinical T3N0 breast cancer was altered by preopera
tive chemotherapy compared with surgery de novo.
Methods: Between 1976 and 1994, 91 patients with clinically node-negative o
perable T3 breast cancer received doxorubicin-based combination chemotherap
y on protocol at one institution. Fifty-three patients received both preope
rative and postoperative chemotherapy (PreopCT), and 38 received postoperat
ive chemotherapy only (PostopCT). All patients underwent axillary lymph nod
e dissection as part of their definitive surgical treatment. There were no
differences between the PreopCT and PostopCT groups in median age (51 vs. 4
9 years), median tumor size at presentation (6 cm vs. 6 cm), tumor grade, o
r estrogen receptor status (estrogen receptor negative 38% vs. 32%). The me
dian follow-up time was 7 years.
Results: Patients in the PreopCT group had fewer histologically positive ly
mph nodes (median, 0 vs. 3, P < .01), and a lower incidence of extranodal e
xtension (19% vs. 42%, P = .02). By univariate analysis, the number of path
ologically positive lymph nodes (P < .01) and extranodal extension (P < .01
) were predictors of disease-specific survival in PreopCT patients. Multiva
riate analysis showed that extranodal extension was the only independent pr
ognostic factor in PreopCT patients (P < .01). Overall, PreopCT and PostopC
T patients had similar 5-year disease-free survival rates (66% vs. 57%); ho
wever, PreopCT patients had worse disease-free (P = .01) and disease-specif
ic survival (P = .04) when survival was compared after adjustment for the n
umber of positive lymph nodes. Furthermore, PreopCT patients with 4-9 posit
ive lymph nodes had a lower 5-year disease-free survival rate than PostopCT
patients with 4-9 positive nodes (17 vs. 48%, P = .04).
Conclusions: Axillary lymph node status remains prognostic after chemothera
py. Pathologically positive lymph nodes after preoperative chemotherapy are
associated with a worse prognosis than the same nodal status before chemot
herapy.