Transcutaneously tunneled central venous lines in cancer patients: An analysis of device-related morbidity factors based on prospective data collection
Re. Schwarz et al., Transcutaneously tunneled central venous lines in cancer patients: An analysis of device-related morbidity factors based on prospective data collection, ANN SURG O, 7(6), 2000, pp. 441-449
Background: Long-term transcutaneous tunneled central venous catheters are
frequently placed in cancer patients, accounting for significant costs and
morbidity. Factors influencing outcome, though, are poorly studied.
Methods: Between June 1991 and June 1993, 923 central venous tunneled cathe
ters were placed in 791 patients at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center.
Placement-, device-, and patient-related parameters were charted prospecti
vely (median follow-up: 120 days) and correlated to device-specific outcome
events.
Results: Median patient age was 28.5 years (range: 0.025 - 84.5). Disease d
istribution included hematologic malignancies (64.7%), solid tumors (30.4%)
, and others (4.9%). Primary indications for line access included chemother
apy (72.8%), bone marrow transplantation (18.7%), total parenteral nutritio
n (6.4%), and drug administration (2.1%). There were 11 insertion complicat
ions (1.2%), including insertion failure (n = 6), hemorrhage (n = 4), and m
alposition (n = 1). Subsequent to placement, a proven or suspected device-s
pecific complication occurred in 540 lines (58.5%). Per 10,000 catheter day
s, there were 17.6 infection episodes, 8.1 thrombotic complications, 6.9 in
stances of catheter breakage, 3.5 accidental or inadvertent cases of displa
cement, and 0.6 device leaks. Reasons for Line removal or other termination
of follow-up were patient's death (32.1%), treatment end (28%), infection
(19.6%), suspected infection (6.3%), displacement (6.8%), thrombosis (3.1%)
, leak (1%), and others (3.1%). Median device-specific duration was 365 day
s, compared with a median complication-free device-specific duration of 167
days (P < 0.0001), reflecting a highly significant device salvage rate aft
er complications. Catheter tip position emerged as the dominant independent
prognostic factor for reduced device-specific duration or complication-fre
e device-specific duration.
Conclusions: Transcutaneous tunneled central venous lines can be placed saf
ely, with a considerable incidence of subsequent device-specific complicati
ons, but a high salvage rate. Factors determining outcome are related to de
vice placement, as well as the patient's disease status. In this study, pat
ients alive 90 days after catheter placement had a 37% chance for a device
complication, with a 20% chance for device loss. Future analyses of interme
diate-term intravenous access should employ the measurement of device-speci
fic outcome as a reference parameter to assess clinical results.