Sy. Hwang et Rl. Lindroth, CLONAL VARIATION IN FOLIAR CHEMISTRY OF ASPEN - EFFECTS ON GYPSY MOTHS AND FOREST TENT CATERPILLARS, Oecologia, 111(1), 1997, pp. 99-108
Quaking aspen (Populus tremuloides) exhibits striking intraspecific va
riation in concentrations of phenolic glycosides, compounds that play
important roles in mediating interactions with herbivorous insects. Th
is research was conducted to assess the contribution of genetic variat
ion to overall phenotypic variation in aspen chemistry and interaction
s with gypsy moths (Lymantria dispar) and forest tent caterpillars (Ma
lacosoma disstria). Thirteen aspen clones were propagated from field-c
ollected root material. Insect performance assays, measuring survival,
development, growth, and food utilization indices, were conducted wit
h second and/or fourth instars. Leaf samples were assayed for water, n
itrogen, total nonstructural carbohydrates, condensed tannins, and phe
nolic glycosides. Results showed substantial among-clone Variation in
the performance of both insect species. Chemical analyses revealed sig
nificant among-clone variation in all foliar constituents and that var
iation in allelochemical contents differed more than variation in prim
ary metabolites. Regression analyses indicated that phenolic glycoside
s were the dominant factor responsible for among-clone variation in in
sect performance. We also found significant genetic trade-offs between
growth and defense among aspen clones. Our results suggest that genet
ic factors are likely responsible for much of the tremendous phenotypi
c variation in secondary chemistry exhibited by aspen, and that the ge
netic structure of aspen populations may play important roles in the e
volution of interactions with phytophagous insects.