The purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between stude
nts' prior work experience and subsequent success during the first year in
an MBA program. We present a rationale for the use of work experience as a
selection criterion (based on the training-readiness literature) but also p
resent another argument (based on the career-stage literature) that counter
s the prevailing view about the appropriateness of this selection standard.
Using data from a unique sample of 230 MBA students and controlling for su
ch factors as the type of undergraduate program attended, undergraduate GPA
, and total score on the Graduate Management Admission Test, prior work exp
erience was found to account for only a small proportion of the variance in
first-semester grades and was found to be unrelated to academic performanc
e in the second semester. Taking these results and other existing empirical
studies into account, there is little support for the view that previous w
ork experience (as assessed by typical admission procedures) leads to highe
r levels of academic achievement. Implications for admissions policy, hirin
g companies, and those considering graduate study in business are discussed
.