P. Colombo, The issue of executive power in the institutional evolution and political debate of the French Revolution, ANN HIST R, (319), 2000, pp. 1-26
The author shows that the issue of executive power is central to the evolvi
ng institutions and political debate of a revolution which has always been
thought of as basically "legicentrist." A remarkable continuity in this res
pect is to be found throughout all the revolutionary phases. Constitutional
monarchy cannot be reduced to the problem of the fate of the royalty, just
as Year VIII cannot be reduced to the coup of Brumaire. So too, the period
of Commitee rule was not only a phase of emergency government, but likewis
e paved the way for the idea of "representative government" and the advent
of collegiate rule. An analysis of the archival records by the author also
shows the multiple solutions developed by the Thermidorian constituents. Th
e need to reduce the split produced in the early days of the Revolution bet
ween wishful thinking and getting things done, is thus very evident in the
debate of 1789 to 1793 and is manifest in the search for the lost pensee du
gouvernment. A striving for a less rigid separation of powers and more ela
stic constitutional rules is clearly discernible.