S. Hood et al., Are there age and sex differences in the investigation and treatment of heart failure? A population-based study, BR J GEN PR, 50(456), 2000, pp. 559-563
Background. Heart failure is a serious, common, and growing problem. Hospit
al admissions, which account for the bulk of health service costs associate
d with heart failure, are becoming more frequent
Aim. To determine whether management of heart failure differs by age and se
x.
Method. A retrospective case note review of prevalent cases in 16 general p
ractices in West London. Five hundred and eighty-three patients (57% women)
with a diagnosis of heart failure were reviewed.
Results. Mean age of patients with heart failure was 78 years (SD = 9.5) -
74 years at diagnosis (SD = 10) - and was higher for women than men (76 yea
rs versus 71 years, P<0.007). In 32% of patients there was no record of a c
hest X-ray, electrocardiogram, or echocardiogram to support diagnosis. Echo
cardiography, performed in 34% of patients, was less likely in older patien
ts in both sexes (test for trend P = 0.04 in women and 0.02 in men) and, ov
erall, in women (29% compared with 40% of men, P = 0.006). Angiotensin-conv
erting enzyme (ACE) inhibitor treatment, recorded in 54% of patients, decre
ased with age in both sexes (P<0.001) and, on unadjusted data, was more lik
ely in men than in women (61% compared with 49%, P = 0005). On adjustment f
or age, sex differences in the use of echocardiography and ACE inhibitors w
ere reduced and no longer significant.
Conclusions. With increasing age, men and women with heart failure were les
s likely to have undergone echocardiography or to have received an ACE inhi
bitor. When account was taken of age, there were no statistically significa
nt sex differences in management; however, because of the demographic distr
ibution of heart failure, women are disproportionately affected by age diff
erences in management. Clinical trials, physician practice, and service dev
elopments in heart failure have neglected older people. This balance should
be redressed.