Nine commercially available true potato seed (TPS) hybrids were compar
ed to four standard clonal cultivars with respect to mean and uniformi
ty of foliar characteristics and tuber traits important to the North A
merican potato industry. The TPS hybrids were planted using second veg
etative generation tubers derived originally from botanical seed. Ten
plants from each plot were individually evaluated for plant height, vi
ne maturity, early blight symptoms, and verticillium wilt symptoms. Fo
llowing harvest, yield was determined and the tubers were rated or mea
sured for appearance, shape, specific gravity, and french fry color. T
he TPS hybrids had mean values for all tuber and foliar traits, except
plant height, that were not significantly different from those of one
or more of the cultivars; generally, values for the hybrids fell amid
those of the cultivars. Two of the hybrids were taller on average tha
n any of the four cultivars. In contrast to the means, trait uniformit
y of the TPS hybrids was consistently less than for the cultivars. For
all foliar traits, except plant height, the TPS hybrids were substant
ially less uniform than the standard cultivars. For specific gravity a
nd french fry color, two important processing quality traits, the hybr
ids tended to be less uniform than the cultivars; however, the differe
nce was much less pronounced than for the foliar traits. Four of the h
ybrids were not significantly less uniform than one or more of the cul
tivars for french fry color and seven were not less uniform for specif
ic gravity. For many market uses, the TPS hybrids appeared to have the
tuber yield and quality characteristics needed to compete with standa
rd clonally propagated cultivars.