An extensive Monte Carlo study has been made of tracer correlation factors
in simple cubic, bcc and fee binary random alloys. Contrary to the findings
of much of the earlier Monte Carlo work, where vacancy jump sequences were
much too short, we found that generally Manning's diffusion kinetics forma
lism (Manning, J. R., 1968, Diffusion kinetics for Atoms ill Crystals; 1971
, Phys. Rev. B, 4, 1111) provides only a fairly rough approximation for the
tracer correlation factors except when the exchange frequency ratio is clo
se to unity. It is found that the Holdsworth, P. C. and Elliott, R. J. (198
6, Phil. Mag. A, 54, 601) kinetics formalism performs much better than Mann
ing's over a wide range of exchange frequency ratios and, for the slow diff
user, is almost exact. The kinetics Formalism of Moleko, L. K., Allnatt, A.
R., and Allnatt, E. L., (1989, Phil. Mag. A, 59, 141) performs even better
, with essentially exact agreement for the slow diffuser, and excellent agr
eement for the faster diffuser except for extreme values of the exchange fr
equency ratio.