The question surrounding the colonization of Polynesia has remained controv
ersial. Two hypotheses, one postulating Taiwan as the putative homeland and
the other asserting a Melanesian origin of the Polynesian people, have rec
eived considerable attention. In this work, we present haplotype data based
on the distribution of 19 biallelic polymorphisms on the Y chromosome in a
sample of 551 male individuals from 36 populations living in Southeast Asi
a, Taiwan, Micronesia, Melanesia, and Polynesia. Surprisingly, nearly none
of the Taiwanese Y haplotypes were found in Micronesia and Polynesia. Likew
ise, a Melanesian-specific haplotype was not found among the Polynesians. H
owever, all of the Polynesian, Micronesian, and Taiwanese haplotypes are pr
esent in the extant Southeast Asian populations. Evidently, the Y-chromosom
e data do not lend support to either of the prevailing hypotheses. Rather,
we postulate that Southeast Asia provided a genetic source for two independ
ent migrations, one toward Taiwan and the other toward Polynesia through is
land Southeast Asia.