Rb. Pierce et al., PHOTOCHEMICAL CALCULATIONS ALONG AIR-MASS TRAJECTORIES DURING ASHOE MAESA/, JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-ATMOSPHERES, 102(11D), 1997, pp. 13153-13167
The practicality of conducting photochemical calculations along trajec
tories of air masses is investigated. An isentropic trajectory package
is used in conjunction with a detailed photochemical model to compare
predictions of the mean chemical content of air masses initialized wi
th the Halogen Occultation Experiment (HALOE) data with coincident in
situ observations from instruments onboard the ER-2 aircraft. Comparis
ons are made for 10 ER-2 flights originating from Christchurch, New Ze
aland, during the May to June and October 1994 Airborne Southern Hemis
phere Ozone Experiment/Measurements for Assessing the Effects of Strat
ospheric Aircraft (ASHOE/MAESA) deployments. Between 54 and 84 coincid
ences are found, depending on the species measured. Correlations betwe
en the ER-2 and HALOE air mass/box model calculations are high (0.56-0
.90) for most species considered except for H2O (0.14) and HCl (0.24).
Statistically significant low biases in the prediction of HCl, H2O, a
nd OH are found. Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) significance tests are used t
o quantify the agreement between the distribution of species observed
by the ER-2 and predicted by the HALOE trajectory/photochemical model.
The model predictions agree with the observed variance within the dis
tributions at significance levels greater than 0.80 (greater than 80%
confidence that the predicted and observed variance are identical) for
H2O, ClO, O-3, and NOy. The impact of computational errors in the tra
jectory calculations and measurement uncertainty in the computed confi
dence levels are investigated using Monte Carlo techniques. Computatio
nal trajectory errors are found to play a small role in reducing confi
dence levels. The error analysis shows that the HALOE trajectory/photo
chemical model calculations reproduce the large-scale variability foun
d in the in situ ER-2 constituent measurements to within the expected
uncertainties in the HALOE observations for all species considered. It
is concluded that the combined trajectory/photochemical model is an e
ffective tool for interpreting in situ aircraft observations within th
e global perspective provided by remote satellite measurements.