M. Robert et al., Piezoelectric ESWL of ureteric stones. Influence of the site and dimensions of the stones on treatment modalities and performances., PROG UROL, 10(3), 2000, pp. 397-403
Objective: To evaluate the influence of the site and dimensions of ureteric
stones on the modalities and performances of in situ piezoelectric extraco
rporeal shockwave lithotripsy (ESWL).
Material and Methods: A population of 385 patients with solitary radiopaque
ureteric stones was analysed. The long axis of these stones (211 (55%) lum
bar 38 (10%) iliac and 136 (35%) pelvic stones) ranged from 5 to 21 mm (mea
n = 8.2 mm). The initial shock wave frequency was 4/s. Lumbar stones were t
reated in the dorsal supine position under diazanalgesia and pelvic stones
were treated in the ventral supine position without systematic sedation. Th
e influence of wave frequency (1 versus 4/s) on the level of sedation and t
herapeutic performances was studied on 146 patients with lumbar (n=92) or p
elvic stones (n=54), The results were evaluated after only one ESWL session
and were analysed statistically by Student's test and Fisher test.
Results: The overall complete success rate was 74%, Iliac stones were chara
cterized by significantly (p<0.05) lower (61%) performances. The results we
re inversely proportional to the size of the stones, as the complete succes
s rate was only 25% for stones >12 mm. For lumbar stones, a lower frequency
allowed a very significant reduction (p<0.0001) of the level of sedation r
equired without affecting the performance. For pelvic stones, a low frequen
cy significantly (p<0.05) limited the efficacy of ESWL, especially for ston
es >8 mm (27% of complete successes).
Conclusion: In situ piezoelectric ESWL allows effective management of most
ureteric stones with of long axis between 5 and 10 mm. In the context of ou
tpatient treatment, however; this approach requires modulation of the shock
wave frequency according to the site of the stone. Another therapeutic app
roach, particularly endoscopy, should be considered for very large stones.