M. Lynch et D. Bogen, SOCIOLOGY ASOCIOLOGICAL CORE - AN EXAMINATION OF TEXTBOOK SOCIOLOGY IN LIGHT OF THE SOCIOLOGY OF SCIENTIFIC KNOWLEDGE, American sociological review, 62(3), 1997, pp. 481-493
The sociology of scientific knowledge (SSK) has challenged many of the
''core'' conceptions of theory and method that remain entrenched in s
ociology textbooks. In conjunction with recent developments in history
and philosophy of science, sociologists of science speak of the disun
ity of science and describe the local-historical origins of particular
scientific facts and laws. ''Core'' sociology textbooks devote no att
ention to the methodological implications of recent sociology of scien
ce. Elementary textbooks present upbeat versions of the discipline tha
t emphasize sociology's scientific methodology; they describe sociolog
ical methods as implementations of a general research process designed
along hypothetico-dedective lines. Viewed from the vantage point of S
SK, such widely disseminated elementary versions of sociology promote
an asociological conception of science. In this paper we suggest that
the ''epistemic flattening'' accomplished by SSK's research on the nat
ural sciences provides a valuable antidote to current anxieties about
the coherence and scientific status of sociology.