Despite widespread use of various tetrazolium assays, the mechanisms of bio
reduction of these compounds have not been fully elucidated. We investigate
d the capacity of tetrazolium salts to penetrate through intact cell plasma
membranes. 5-cyano-2,3-ditolyl tetrazolium chloride (CTC) and 3-(4,5-dimet
hylthiazol-2-yl)-2,5 diphenyltetrazolium bromide (MTT) tetrazolium salts ap
pear to represent examples of species that are reduced by different mechani
sms. We provide evidence suggesting that MTT readily crosses intact plasma
membranes and is reduced intracellularly. MTT appears to be reduced by both
plasma membrane and intracellular reductases; reducing cells are not damag
ed and remain metabolically active for at least 45 min. In contrast, CTC re
mains extracellular with respect to viable cells and thus requires plasma m
embrane permeable electron carrier to be reduced efficiently. However, redu
ction of CTC in the presence of an electron carrier inflicts damage on plas
ma membranes. The intracellular vs extracellular sites of reduction of tetr
azolium salts were established on the basis of deposition of formazans. Cry
stals of formazan were detected using fluorescence or backscattered light c
onfocal laser microscopy. We postulate that the capacity of a tetrazolium s
alt to cross intact plasma membranes constitutes an important experimental
variable which needs to be controlled in order to correctly interpret the o
utcome of tetrazolium assays designed to measure cellular production of oxy
gen radicals, activity of mitochondrial, cytosolic, or outer membrane reduc
tases, etc. (C)2000AcademicPress.