The physical differences between facial expressions (e.g. fear) and a refer
ence norm (e.g. a neutral expression) were altered to produce photographic-
quality caricatures. In Experiment 1, participants rated caricatures of fea
r, happiness and sadness for their intensity of these three emotions; a sec
ond group of participants rated how 'face-like' the caricatures appeared. W
ith increasing levels of exaggeration the caricatures were rated as more em
otionally intense, but less 'face-like'. Experiment 2 demonstrated a simila
r relationship between emotional intensity and level of caricature for six
different facial expressions. Experiments 3 and 4 compared intensity rating
s of facial expression caricatures prepared relative to a selection of refe
rence norms - a neutral expression, an average expression, or a different f
acial expression (e,g, anger caricatured relative to fear). Each norm produ
ced a linear relationship between caricature and rated intensity of emotion
; this finding is inconsistent with two-dimensional models of the perceptua
l representation of facial expression, An exemplar-based multidimensional m
odel is proposed as an alternative account. (C) 2000 Elsevier Science B.V.
All rights reserved.