Pr. Williamson et al., Individual patient data meta-analysis of randomized anti-epilepatic drug monotherapy trials, J EVAL CL P, 6(2), 2000, pp. 205-214
Meta-analysis may be based on either aggregate data or individual patient d
ata (IPD). Three reasons why IPD are desirable for the meta-anlysis of anti
-epileptic drug (AED) monotherapy trials are: (1) to undertake a more compl
ete analysis of time-to-event outcomes; (2) to investigate the interaction
between AED and type of epilepsy; and (3) to undertake re-analysis of the t
rial to obtain results for all relevant outcomes. We demonstrate that IPD m
eta-analysis is possible in AED research. Problems arose from missing data
at four levels: (1) unknown trials; (2) known trials but no IPD supplied; (
3) known trials but missing outcome data for some individuals within trials
; and (4) known trials but missing covariate data for some-individuals with
in trials. Empirical evidence of the reliability of meta-analyses based on
aggregate rather than individual patient data is still lacking. Examples of
other benefits such projects may bring include: improvements to the design
of a new trial in the area,in terms of the sample size considerations, the
definition of outcomes and data collection.