The clustered Hox genes show a conserved role in patterning the body axis o
f bilaterian metazoans. Increasingly, a broader phylogenetic sampling of no
n-model system organisms is being examined to detect a correlation, if any,
between Hox gene evolution, and body plan innovations. To assess how Hox g
ene expression and function evolve with changing cluster arrangements, we m
ust be able to reliably assign gene orthologies between Hox genes. Recent e
vidence suggests that a four-gene proto-Hox cluster duplicated to form the
precursor of the present cluster and an additional sister-cluster, the Para
Hox group. Here, phylogenetic methods are used to determine Hox-gene orthol
ogies and to infer probable clustering events leading to the current bilate
rian Hox complement. This analysis supports the ParaHox hypothesis and give
s first confirmation that ind (intermediate neuroblasts defective) is an an
terior ParaHox ortholog from protostomes. This analysis supports a proto-Ho
x cluster of four genes in which the central-class member of the ParaHox cl
uster may have been lost. It is also proposed here that ancestral diploblas
ts had central-class members of both Hox and ParaHox clusters. Primitive Ho
x gene ancestors are estimated by phylogenetic methods and found to have no
strong affinity to any particular class of extant Hox members. (C) 2000 Wi
ley-Liss, Inc.