Two computational models of lexical access in aphasic speakers are compared
. Both are derived from an interactive two-step theory of retrieval based o
n spreading activation. The weight-decay model (Dell et al., 1997) associat
es patients with deviant values of two parameters, global connection weight
and global decal rate. The new semantic-phonological model characterizes p
atients by two different parameters, semantic weight and phonological weigh
t. We provide a detailed analysis of the properties of both models and show
that the semantic-phonological model is a serious competitor to the earlie
r model. Not only does it fit existing patient data as well as the weight-d
ecay model does but it also has closer ties to other facts and theories in
cognitive neuropsychology and psycholinguistics. (C) 2000 Academic Press.