The time course of intensive care for severe respiratory syncytial virus (R
SV) lower respiratory tract illness may be predicted by the severity of gas
exchange during the first 48 h of mechanical ventilation. To test this hyp
othesis, two studies were undertaken in RSV-positive mechanically ventilate
d patients who did not have chronic lung disease, congenital heart disease
or immunodeficiency. First, a retrospective criteria-generating review of 4
5 infants was carried out. In these infants, more severe lower airway disea
se, as demonstrated by four-quadrant consolidation on chest X-ray, was asso
ciated with 'best' alveolar arterial oxygen gradients (AaDO(2), torr) and m
ean airway pressure (MAP,cm H2O) values as follows: first 24 h, AaDO(2) > 4
00 and MAP > 10 (positive and negative predictive values 100% and 97%, resp
ectively); second 24 h, AaDO(2) greater than or equal to 300 and MAP > 10 (
positive and negative predictive values 91% and 100%, respectively). The se
cond study, a prospective, hypothesis-testing, analysis of length-of-stay i
n 44 infants stratified according to the above AaDO(2) and MAP criteria dem
onstrated that the duration of intensive care was longer in the severe grou
p. median (interquartile range in days) 17 (15-39) vs 7 (4-8) (p < 0.01).
We suggest that, in mechanically ventilated infants with RSV, the time cour
se of intensive care is predictable based on early clinical features and re
spiratory parameters, Therefore reports on the effectiveness of special the
rapies using intensive care stay as a measure of outcome should be interpre
ted with respect to these observations before drawing conclusions about eff
icacy.