When normalized by initial surface area, crystalline and amorphous albite r
elease Si and Al at the same rate within error (+/-40%) as measured at pH 2
, 5.6, and 8.4 at 25 degrees C. Differences in density and tetrahedral ring
structure between the glass and crystal structures, however, lead to more
extensive Na and Al depletion from the glass surface, especially in acid. X
-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) indicates that the chemistry of the a
ltered layers on glass and crystal must be significantly different at a dep
th of similar to 17 Angstrom-87 Angstrom. Nevertheless, angle-resolved XPS
(ARXPS) indicates that the outermost 17 Angstrom of the glass and crystal s
urface are compositionally similar. In neutral and weakly basic conditions,
XPS indicates less extensive depletion of Na and Al from reacted glass and
crystal surfaces than in acidic conditions. Al enrichment was not observed
at any pH on either the crystal or glass surface. At steady state, Al rele
ase was stoichiometric for all phases and all pH values, but Na release was
always faster than release of Si, especially for the glass. These results
are consistent with a model where only the outer surface controls dissoluti
on and the deeper layers of the altered surface do not significantly affect
dissolution rate. The similarity in dissolution rate between glass and min
eral, if consistent for other phases, may also indicate that some future st
udies of mineral dissolution could be completed more efficiently by investi
gation of glass because such studies could reveal the chemical effects in d
issolution independent of the microstructure and defects that populate natu
ral mineral samples. Copyright (C) 2000 Elsevier Science Ltd.