The Day plot (M-rs/M-s versus H-cr/H-c) is widely used by paleomagnetists t
o estimate the size of ferromagnetic grains and classify them as single-dom
ain (SD), pseudo-single-domain (PSD,) or multidomain (MD). How reliable is
this plot? To find out, a numerical micromagnetic model is used to calculat
e hysteresis loops as a function of grain size for two grain shapes (cube a
nd cuboid with X = 1.5Y = 1.4Z). Magnetocrystalline anisotropy is ignored.
The average M-rs/M-s is calculated for a collection of randomly oriented gr
ains: In the elongated grain it drops from 0.4 to 0.06 over a negligible si
ze range, almost missing the usual PSD range altogether. Other hysteresis p
arameters, H-c, H-cr, and chi(0), can only be calculated for a grain at a t
ime. This is done for two magnetic field directions (close to the longest a
xis and close to the shortest axis). The single-grain values of H-cr/H-c de
pend strongly on field direction, but it is clear that the average jumps ra
pidly from SD to MD values. There are large, rapid fluctuations in H-cr and
chi(0) associated with changes in rernancnt states. However, these fluctua
tions may not be apparent when averaged over a broad size range. This slay
explain why H-cr and chi(0) depend weakly on grain size in real samples. In
the size range studied (L less than or equal to 0.25 mu m), hysteresis par
ameters do not represent a typical grain size. Instead, they depend strongl
y on the size distribution.