Genetics services in a social, ethical and policy context: a collaborationbetween consumers and providers

We report a unique, collaborative effort by users and providers of genetic services to arrive at outlines for optimal ethics and clinical practice. Us ing focus groups of consumers (users) and providers (held separately), a pr ovider-consumer project team developed 1) a consumer wish list, 2) an exper ientially based ethical overview of situations arising in practice, and 3) detailed suggestions for consumer-provider interactions in clinical setting s. Consumers were primarily interested in accurate information, respect for persons, a smoothly functioning team, with the consumer as an equal member of the team,family integrity, and providers who knew the limits of their k nowledge and were willing to refer. "Non-directive" counselling and privacy were not major issues in consumer focus groups; some thought providers sho uld openly state their own opinions. Providers had a rather different list of priorities. Books and papers on clinical ethics usually originate from bioethicists and physicians. This pilot project is unique in including consumers and provid ers equally.