Limited information is available in maize (Zea mays L.) with respect to the
application of different selection criteria to adapt exotic germplasm to a
particular area. A comparison among different selection criteria could giv
e important information For the efficiency of the selection process. The st
udy was designed to compare the responses to different mass selection crite
ria for adaptation applied over the same original population. Four cycles o
f selection were completed for an exotic maize population. Selection was ba
sed on six criteria, PEG (prolificacy, ear length, and grain length); RTO (
individual plant yield); PRE (early silk emergence); HI (harvest index); PE
(prolificacy and ear length), and ASI (anthesis-silking interval). The ori
ginal population and four cycles corresponding to each criterion were teste
d For grain yield response during three consecutive years. Ten random famil
ies derived from each four-selection criterion were evaluated For morpholog
ical characters during two years. Grain yield increased significantly from
C0 to C4 with the application of all selection criteria, with the exception
of HI criterion. increases in grain yield expressed as average response, w
ere 3,2% for PKE, ASI and RTO, 3,1% for PEG, and 2,8% for PE. The HI criter
ion was not effective for adapting exotic germplasm. Mass selection based o
n PRE, ASI, PE, PGE and RTO, were effective in developing populations with
an agronomic performance similar to an adapted population check. Direct sel
ection for yield (RTO) was as effective as indirect selection based in ear
characteristics. The advantage of PRE and ASI criteria in comparison with t
he other criteria applied during this study is that PRE and ASI are more si
mple and accurate to measure a large number of germplasm introductions in f
ield experiments.