Observations in targeted mouse mutants and patients with genetic abnormalit
ies grant insight into the various and distinct roles of insulin-like growt
h factor receptors (IGF-Rs) and insulin receptors (IRs) during early develo
pment. While IGF-1Rs (mediating both IGF-1 and IGF-2 actions) are important
for embryonic and fetal growth, IRs (mediating IGF-2 rather than insulin a
ction) play a minor role. However, it is an oversimplification to conclude
that IGF-1Rs mediate growth and IRs mediate metabolic responses. Mice lacki
ng both IRs and IGF-1Rs are more severely growth retarded than mice lacking
either receptor alone. The phenotype of combined deficiency of IRs and IGF
-1Rs is similar to the phenotype caused by the absence of IGF-1 and IGF-2.
This provides genetic proof that these two receptors account for the entire
ty of the growth promoting effects of IGF-1 and IGF-2. There is little evid
ence that hybrid insulin/IGF-1 receptors promote embryonic growth to a sign
ificant degree. The clinical presentation regarding severity of growth reta
rdation and metabolic disturbances observed in animal models versus in huma
ns may differ greatly and the reasons will be reviewed in detail.