Teacher educators face a dilemma: How do we prepare preservice teachers to
pass new high-stakes certification tests when these tests are often based o
n philosophical perspectives that run counter to our own beliefs about lite
racy, learning, and teaching. In this article, the authors offer an inquiry
-oriented approach that uses the lens of the New Literacy Studies to help p
rospective teachers simultaneously prepare for and critique high-stakes sta
ndardized tests such as the Communication and Literacy Skills (CLS) portion
of the Massachusetts Educator Certification Tests. The authors describe a
specific activity, inviting preservice teachers to explore the social natur
e of literacies, investigate the characteristics of the CLS, and reflect on
this type of high-stakes assessment. After providing a critique of the CLS
test based on this type of activity, the authors offer recommendations for
more extended activities to be used in teacher education courses.