Ed. Carrol et al., Performance characteristics of the polymerase chain reaction assay to confirm clinical meningococcal disease, ARCH DIS CH, 83(3), 2000, pp. 271-273
Background-Confirmation of clinical meningococcal disease (MCD) is essentia
l for management of patients, contacts, and outbreaks. Blood and CSF cultur
es, the traditional gold standard diagnostic tests, have been adversely aff
ected by preadmission parenteral penicillin and fewer lumbar punctures. Rap
id, reliable serogroup determination without the need to grow isolates coul
d improve laboratory confirmation of MCD.
Aims-To determine performance characteristics of the currently available me
ningococcal polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assays in a clinical setting.
Methods-Prospective study of 319 children presenting with a suspected diagn
osis of MCD (fever and a rash, or suspected bacterial meningitis) over a 16
month period.
Results-A total of 166 (52% of all) children had clinical MCD: diagnosis wa
s confirmed microbiologically in 119 (72%) of these. Performance characteri
stics (sensitivity, specificity, negative predictive value, positive predic
tive value) in confirmation of clinical MCD were respectively (95% confiden
ce interval): blood culture 31% (24-38%), 100%, 57% (49-65%), 100%; blood P
CR 47% (39-55%), 100%, 65% (58-73%), 100%; any test positive 72% (65-79%),
100%, 77% (70-84%), 100%.
Conclusions-Meningococcal DNA detection in blood or CSF by PCR is a useful
method of diagnosis of MCD. PCR of peripheral blood performs better than bl
ood culture. In a child with clinically suspected MCD, PCR assays, bacteria
l antigen tests, and oropharyngeal swabbing for meningococcal carriage shou
ld be performed in addition to blood or CSF culture, to improve case confir
mation.