In his third social survey of York carried our in 1950, Seebohm Rowntree re
ported a steep decline since 1936 of the percentage of households in povert
y. He attributed the bulk of this decline to government welfare reforms ena
cted during and after the war. This article re-examines the surviving recor
ds from the 1950 survey, using a revised poverty line and looking more clos
ely at the measurement of income. It also re-assesses the impact of welfare
reforms on working-class poverty, and finds that poverty in York was signi
ficantly higher, and the contribution of welfare reform substantially less,
than was originally reported.