Rj. Calantone et al., NEW PRODUCT ACTIVITIES AND PERFORMANCE - THE MODERATING ROLE OF ENVIRONMENTAL HOSTILITY, The Journal of product innovation management, 14(3), 1997, pp. 179-189
In the race to bring new products to market, a company may be tempted
to cut corners in the new product development (NPD) process. And a hos
tile environment-that is, one marked by intense competition and rapid
technological change-only heightens the pressure to reduce NPD cycle t
ime. However, hasty completion of the NPD process may actually jeopard
ize a product's chances for success. In a study of Fortune 500 manufac
turers of industrial products, Roger, J. Calantone, Jeffrey B. Schmidt
, and C. Anthony Di Benedetto explore the relationships among new prod
uct success rates, proficiency in the execution of NPD activities, and
the perceived level of hostility in the competitive environment. Thei
r study examines how proficiency in NPD activities affects the odds of
success for industrial new products. Adding environmental hostility t
o the mix, they also investigate whether the perceived level of hostil
ity in the competitive environment affects the relationship between NP
D proficiency and success. In this way, they provide insight into the
factors managers must consider when attempting to accelerate cycle tim
e in a hostile competitive environment. The respondents to their surve
y-142 senior managers involved in NPD or product innovation rated envi
ronmental hostility in terms of the extent to which the firm perceives
its industry as safe, rich in investment opportunity, and controllabl
e. To assess NPD proficiency, respondents were asked about their firms
' performance in predevelopment marketing and technical activities, de
velopment marketing and technical activities, and financial analysis.
Respondents assessed new product performance in terms of product profi
tability. As expected, the responses indicate that proficiency in the
performance of NPD activities increases the likelihood of new product
success. Proficiency in development marketing activities produced the
largest increase in likelihood of success-nearly 25 percent over that
of projects in which respondents rated performance of these activities
at any level below ''most proficient.'' More importantly, the respons
es indicate that a hostile competitive environment increases the impac
t of NPD proficiency. In other words, by improving performance of key
NPD activities under hostile environmental conditions, a firm can grea
tly increase the likelihood of success for a new industrial product. R
ather than simply cut corners in the NPD process, a firm face with a h
ostile environment must strike a balance between speed and quality of
execution.