Bd. Jordan et al., APOLIPOPROTEIN-E EPSILON-4 ASSOCIATED WITH CHRONIC TRAUMATIC BRAIN INJURY IN BOXING, JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, 278(2), 1997, pp. 136-140
Context.-Given the similarities between Alzheimer disease and dementia
pugilistica, we evaluated the relationship between apolipoprotein E (
APOE) genotype and chronic traumatic brain injury (CTBI) in boxers to
determine whether there is a genetic susceptibility to the effects of
head trauma. Objective.-To assess the relationship between CTBI and AP
OE genotype in boxers. Design and Setting.-Clinical characterization o
f 24 volunteer and 6 referred boxers in an outpatient setting. Partici
pants.-Thirty professional boxers aged 23 to 76 years underwent neurol
ogic and behavioral assessment in conjunction with APOE genotyping. Ma
in Outcome Measures.-Apolipoprotein E genotype was examined in relatio
nship to measures of CTBI. A 10-point clinical rating scale (0-9), the
Chronic Brain Injury (CBI) scale, was devised to assess the severity
of traumatic encephalopathy associated with boxing, Boxers with abnorm
al CTBI scores were further classified on the basis of whether their i
mpairments were possibly or probably related to boxing. Scores were an
alyzed in relation to boxing exposure (number of bouts) and APOE genot
ype. Results.-Among the 30 boxers, 11 were found to be normal (CBI sco
re=0), 12 showed mild deficits (CBI score=1-2), 4 were moderately impa
ired (CBI score=3-4), and 3 showed signs of severe impairment (CBI sco
re >4). High-exposure boxers tie, those with greater than or equal to
12 professional bouts) had significantly higher CBI scores (mean [SD],
2.6 [1.9]) than low-exposure boxers (mean [SD], 0.3 [0.7]) (P<.001),
indicating that neurologic impairment as measured by the CBI scale see
ms related to boxing exposure. The APOE genotype frequencies of the st
udy population were approximately the same as those found in the gener
al population. Boxers with low exposure had mean CBI scores of 0.33, i
rrespective of APOE genotype. However, high-exposure boxers with an AP
OE epsilon 4 allele had significantly greater CBI scores (mean [SD], 3
.9 [2.3]) than high-exposure boxers without APOE epsilon 4 (mean [SD],
1.8 [1.2]) (P=.04), All boxers with severe impairment possessed at le
ast 1 APOE epsilon 4 allele. The tendency for greater CTBI among those
with both high exposure and an epsilon 4 allele was statistically sig
nificant at the P<.001 level. ConcIusions.-These preliminary findings
suggest that possession or an APOE epsilon 4 allele may be associated
with increased severity of chronic neurologic deficits in high-exposur
e boxers.