In this paper we use an extensive archive of early New Zealand speakers, to
gether with comparisons with the other Southern Hemisphere varieties of Eng
lish, to argue that dialect mixture and new-dialect formation are not hapha
zard processes. We demonstrate that, given sufficient linguistic informatio
n about the dialects which contribute to a mixture, and sufficient demograp
hic information about the proportions of speakers of the different dialects
, it is possible to make predictions about what the outcome of the mixture
will be. We also argue that we have arrived at a probabilistic solution to
the problem of randomness in the transmission of dialect features from one
generation to another in such situations.