M. Paciaroni et al., Long-term clinical and angiographic outcomes in symptomatic patients with 70% to 99% carotid artery stenosis, STROKE, 31(9), 2000, pp. 2037-2042
Background and Purpose-In 1991, the North American Symptomatic Carotid Enda
rterectomy Trial (NASCET) reported the benefit of carotid endarterectomy fo
r 659 patients with 70% to 99% stenosis. Follow-up continued until 1997.
Methods-The present study examined the risks and causes of ipsilateral stro
ke in the randomized groups and in those who had delayed endarterectomy or
continued on medical therapy and also examined the evolution of carotid dis
ease on follow-up imaging.
Results-By on-treatment (efficacy) analysis, the risk of any ipsilateral st
roke at 3 years was 28.3% for medically randomized and 8.9% for surgically
randomized patients (19.4% absolute risk reduction, P<0.001). For combined
disabling or fatal ipsilateral stroke, the risks were 14.0% and 3.4%, respe
ctively (10.6% absolute risk reduction). In medical patients, >80% of the f
irst strokes at 3 years were of large-artery origin. After February 1991, 1
16 suitable medical patients underwent endarterectomy within 6 months, and
115 continued on medical therapy. The 3-year risk of any ipsilateral stroke
in the groups of 116 and 115 patients was 7.9% and 15.0%, respectively (7.
1% absolute risk reduction). During follow-up, 81 patients had angiograms c
omparable to the baseline images. Progression by greater than or equal to 1
0% occurred in 7 patients; regression, in 8; no change, in 39; and occlusio
n, in 27. By use of both angiography and ultrasound, 63 (25.5%) of the 247
medically treated patients progressed to occlusion, of whom 31.7% had an ip
silateral stroke before or on the day of occlusion.
Conclusions-Endarterectomy for patients with 70% to 99% stenosis and recent
symptoms was efficacious in the long term. Compared with patients who cont
inued on medical therapy, medical patients with delayed endarterectomy expe
rienced a moderate benefit. Medically treated patients experienced a high r
isk of occlusion.