Rm. Sayre et al., CHANGING THE RISK SPECTRUM OF INJURY AND THE PERFORMANCE OF SUNSCREENPRODUCTS THROUGHOUT THE DAY, Photodermatology, photoimmunology & photomedicine, 10(4), 1994, pp. 148-153
Sunscreen products are tested normally against a defined solar simulat
or spectrum that, in ultraviolet (UVB), closely resembles the noontime
spectral composition of summer sunlight. Although such a spectrum may
define the product for use in the most adverse sunlight conditions, l
ittle attention has been given to how such products perform against ot
her natural sunlight spectra. Outdoor clinical trials suggest that ind
oor testing of sunscreens may overestimate the performance of many pro
ducts. In this study we compared the predicted efficacy of specific pr
oducts to a variety of natural sunlight spectra taken at different sol
ar angles and under different atmospheric conditions. We found that a
standard product always provides less protection for a natural sunligh
t spectrum than its label value would suggest. The deviation from the
labeled value is the greatest when the sun is low in the sky, i.e., cl
ose to the horizon. The deviation is due to the changing ratio of UVA
to UVB radiation in natural sunlight. The deviation can be as large as
a factor of 2.0.