Em. Elson et Ntf. Ridley, Paracetamol as a prophylactic analgesic for hysterosalpingography: A double blind randomized controlled trial, CLIN RADIOL, 55(9), 2000, pp. 675-678
AIM: To evaluate the effectiveness of paracetamol as a prophylactic analges
ic for hysterosalpingography (HSG).
DESIGN: A prospective double blind randomized controlled trial comparing on
e 1 g of paracetamol (SmithKline Beecham, Brentford, U.K.) to placebo taken
30 min before HSG. One hundred consecutive out-patients were studied prosp
ectively, The analgesic effectiveness during the procedure and at 24 h and
1 week post procedure was analysed by a postal pain score questionnaire, Ad
ditional data on the ethnicity of the patient, sex and level of experience
of the radiologist performing the hysterosalpingogram, the parity of the pa
tient, the ease of the procedure, and whether pathology was Identified were
also recorded.
RESULTS: Eighty-eight patients (88%) replied, 39 (44%) received paracetamol
and 39 placebo (56%), During the procedure 3/39 (7%) of women in the parac
etamol group were pain-fret compared to 9/49 (18%) in the placebo group, wh
ich was not significant (P = 0.11). At 24 h, 15/39 (38%) of women in the pa
racetamol group were pain-free compared to 20/49 (41%) in the placebo group
, which was not significant (P = 0.82), At 1 week, 27/39 (69%) of women in
the paracetamol group were pain-free compared to 29/49 (59%) in the placebo
group, which was not significant (P = 0.33). No significant difference in
mean pain stores was determined during the procedure (P = 0.91), or at 24 h
post procedure (P = 0.94). Similarly, no difference in mean pain scores wa
s identified with regard to the ethnicity of the patient, the sex of the ra
diologist performing the procedure, the level of experience of the radiolog
ist performing the procedure, or whether pathology was present or not. Diff
icult cannulations were associated with higher mean pain scores, however, t
here was no difference in mean pain scores between the paracetamol or place
bo groups for both easy and difficult cannulations.
CONCLUSION: Paracetamol is not effective as a prophylactic analgesic for HS
G. If a prophylactic analgesic is considered necessary for pain relief duri
ng HSG we recommend that a non-steriodal anti-inflammatory drug: (NSAID) is
used. (C) 2000 The Royal College of Radiologists.