The validity and reliability of the diagnosis of bipolar II disorder has be
en questioned by means of comorbidity with noneffective disorders, includin
g substance abuse, personality disorders, and anxiety disorders. This study
examined the comorbid diagnosis of a sample of bipolar II patients, compar
ing patients with comorbidity and those with "pure" bipolar II disorder. Fo
rty Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC) bipolar II patients were assessed by
means of the Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia, Lifetime
Version (SADS-L) and Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R axis I (SC
ID-II) for personality disorders, Patients fulfilling RDC criteria for any
psychiatric disorder (except personality disorders) or DSM-IV criteria for
any personality disorder were compared with patients without comorbidity, F
or practical reasons, cyclothymia was not considered as a comorbid diagnosi
s. Half of the sample had lifetime comorbidity with other psychiatric disor
ders, mainly personality disorders (33%), substance abuse or dependence (21
%), and anxiety disorders (8%). However, only the rates of suicidal ideatio
n (74% v 24%, chi square [(2)(chi)] = 9.03, P =.003) and suicide attempts (
45% v 5%, (chi 2) = 8.53, P = .003) were significantly different between pa
tients with and without comorbidity. In summary, although the rates of como
rbidity are relatively high in bipolar II disorder, most clinical and cours
e variables are strikingly similar in patients with and without comorbidity
except for suicidal behavior, suggesting that comorbidity does not reduce
the validity of the diagnosis of bipolar II disorder. Copyright (C) 2000 by
W.B. Saunders Company.