The loading, solubility, mobility, and plant availability of P is a growing
environmental concern to regulators and planners of nutrient management pl
ans, confined animal feeding operations, and wastewater land application pe
rmit sites. Insufficient information is available on how P reacts from diff
erent organic sources when applied to calcareous soils. A field study was c
onducted to determine the interactions among P application rate, source, ex
tractability, and soil organic carbon (OC) concentration. A Portneuf silt l
oam (Coarse-silty, mixed, superactive, mesic Durinodic Xeric Haplocalcids)
topsoil and freshly exposed subsoil were fertilized with monocalcium phosph
ate (MCP), cheese whey, and dairy manure. Organic matter added with the whe
y did not influence soil OC concentrations whereas organic matter added wit
h the manure doubled the subsoil OC and increased the topsoil OC concentrat
ions. Bicarbonate and saturation paste extractable ortho- and organic-P con
centrations were linearly related to soil OC concentrations but were not re
lated to the amount of ortho- or organic-P added. All forms of P increased
more per unit of added P in the order manure > whey > MCP and were correlat
ed with the soil OC concentrations. These results suggest organic waste app
lications should be managed from soil P test data rather than on P applicat
ion rates.