B. Torun et al., Differences in shoot growth and zinc concentration of 164 bread wheat genotypes in a zinc-deficient calcareous soil, J PLANT NUT, 23(9), 2000, pp. 1251-1265
A greenhouse experiment was carried out to study severity of the zinc (Zn)
deficiency symptoms on leaves, shoot dry weight and shoot content and conce
ntration of Zn in 164 winter type bread wheat genotypes (Triticum aestivum
L.) grown in a Zn-deficient calcareous soil with (+Zn = 10 mg Zn kg(-1) soi
l) and without (-Zn) Zn supply for 45 days. Tolerance of the genotypes to Z
n deficiency was ranked based on the relative shoot growth (Zn efficiency r
atio), calculated as the ratio of the shoot dry weight produced under Zn de
ficiency to that produced under adequate Zn supply. There was a substantial
difference in genotypic tolerance to Zn deficiency. Among the 164 genotype
s, 108 genotypes had severe visible symptoms of Zn deficiency (whitish-brow
n necrotic patches) on leaves, while in 25 genotypes Zn deficiency symptoms
were slight or absent, and the remaining genotypes (e.g., 31 genotypes) sh
owed mild deficiency symptoms. Generally, the genotypes with higher toleran
ce to Zn deficiency originated from Balkan countries and Turkey, while geno
types originating from the breeding programs in the Great Plains of the Uni
ted States were mostly sensitive to Zn deficiency. Among the 164 wheat geno
types, Zn efficiency ratio varied from 0.33 to 0.77. The differences in tol
erance to Zn deficiency were totally independent of shoot Zn concentrations
, but showed a close relationship to the total amount (content) of Zn per s
hoot. The absolute shoot growth of the genotypes under Zn deficiency corres
ponded very well with the differences in tolerance to Zn deficiency. Under
adequate Zn supply, the 10 most Zn- inefficient genotypes and the 10 most Z
n-efficient genotypes were very similar in their shoot dry weight. However,
under Zn deficiency, shoot dry weight of the Zn-efficient genotypes was, o
n average, 1.6-fold higher compared to the Zn-inefficient genotypes. The re
sults of this study show large, exploitable genotypic variation for toleran
ce to Zn deficiency in bread wheat. Based on this data, total amount of Zn
per shoot, absolute shoot growth under Zn deficiency, and relative shoot gr
owth can be used as reliable plant parameters for assessing genotypic varia
tion in tolerance to Zn deficiency in bread wheat.