K. Rodewig et al., IS THERE A PARTICULAR VULNERABILITY TO STRESS IN PATIENTS WITH GRAVES-DISEASE, Zeitschrift fur Psycho-somatische Medizin und Psychoanalyse, 43(2), 1997, pp. 153-165
Using a consecutive sample of 19 patients (2 male and 17 female) with
decompensated Graves' disease, and against the background of a controv
ersial scientific discussion, we investigated the following questions:
1. Are there indications of an increased predisposition to stress in
these patients (or a subgroup) and 2. Is there a link between this and
differences in the development of psychopathological complaints? The
status of the psychical symptomatology was evaluated using self-assess
ment questionnaires (STAI X1, X2, BDI, SCL-90-R) at the time of the hy
perthyrosis, and after 3 months of and 1 year of antithyroid drug ther
apy. On the basis of a systematic evaluation of depth-psychology-orien
ted interviews, a relatively little psychologically stressed group (A)
could be distinguished from a relatively severely psychically stresse
d group (B). In the results from the lists of psychopathological sympt
oms, group B showed clearly higher summated values, which also remaine
d at a clearly higher level after normalization of metabolism. By inco
rporating an individual evaluation of the questionnaires, 2 patients c
ould be extracted who, contrary to expectations, showed a worsening of
their psychical symptomatology under normalization of metabolism. The
results of the depth-psychology-oriented interviews, as well as also
the psychological test investigations, support the hypothesis that the
earlier differences in research results can be explained by shortcomi
ngs in methodology, and that a clear indication of a predisposition to
stress is also shown by a subgroup of the Graves' disease patients (i
n our sample 63%) under euthyrosis.